Band: opinion spread · Dot: weighted average
Sources split, and on the most important thing. The layout itself is close to universally liked: chord shapes stay the same in every key and the scale lights keep you in tune, so non-keyboardists get playing quickly. The argument is about the silicone keys. One camp — Audiofanzine, Amazona, both video reviewers and many owners — finds them strikingly sensitive, with plenty of squish for pressure and enough tilt for natural vibrato. The other — bonedo, and owners who returned theirs, often after using a LinnStrument, Osmose or Seaboard — finds them too small and imprecise for nuanced MPE: velocity and pressure arrive together on a hard strike, a slightly off-centre press bends the pitch, sensitivity is hit-and-miss until the curves are edited, and the gaps between keys rule out glides. Both camps describe the same sensor; what differs is how much precise, simultaneous expression the player asks of a key about the size of a two-cent coin.
Measured
Maker spec: 61 hexagonal keys sensitive to pressure (Z axis) and position (X and Y axes), RGB-backlit, velocity-sensitive on note-on and note-off. In MPE mode each note gets its own channel with pitch bend on X, CC74 on Y and aftertouch on Z; a single-channel polyphonic-aftertouch mode (Z only) serves non-MPE synths. Up to 8 note layouts and 32 scales are stored on the keyboard, and the app edits the sensitivity curves.
vs. listeners — The spec does not settle the split, and the maker's own forum shows why both camps exist: one owner found the pressure range concentrated at the top of the key travel and another kept bending pitch by accident at the default 48-semitone bend range — both answered with 'edit the curves'. The maker blamed bonedo's poor result on a sensitivity setting turned too high. Sensitivity is adjustable; whether it can be made precise enough for a given player is exactly what the owners disagree on.
“Les touches répondent avec une précision impressionnante aux moindres variations de pression.”
Alain M. · Audiofanzine (French)
“Aber hier nuancierter, dynamischer und mit mehr Modulationen zu spielen, ist wegen den doch ziemlich klein geratenen Pads und ihrer eher wackeligen Konstruktion eher Glückssache.”
Julian Schmauch · bonedo.de (German)
