Band: opinion spread · Dot: weighted average
Sources split, and the line runs between listening and measuring. Most editorial reviewers hear a natural, smooth, neutral-to-warm balance and treat it as the point of the product. Every measurement rig, the critics and a sizeable share of owners describe a coloured, V-shaped voicing — heavy bass, recessed presence, a lifted top — that many of them correct with the app's EQ. Owners who keep it often say they turned the bass down a notch.
Measured
RTINGS (B&K 5128, bought unit) reads Sound Signature “≈ V-Shaped”, Bass Amount “Very Emphasized (5 dB)” and Treble Amount “Balanced (-1 dB)”. Three independent squig rigs agree on the shape: relative to the HD 600 measured on the same rig, DHRME and Kuulokenurkka show roughly +13 dB at 50 Hz, an 8–11 dB deficit at 2–3.5 kHz and a 6–11 dB excess at 8–9 kHz; Earphones Archive's B&K 5128 trace sits about 15 dB above its diffuse-field target at 50 Hz and 4–9 dB below it at 2.5–3.5 kHz, and that database grades it C+ against B+ for the HD 600 and HD 650.
vs. listeners — The measurements are unambiguous about the shape, so the split is about how that shape lands. A deep presence dip pulls the upper mids back and the bass shelf fills in underneath, which many listeners read as smooth, full and 'natural' rather than as a dip; the 8 kHz lift then supplies the sense of detail. Listeners who hear it as V-shaped are hearing the same graph described the other way round. Sound & Vision's reviewer hears 'neutral with perhaps a slight warmth' — a fair summary of how the camp that likes it experiences a headphone that measures far from neutral.
“Add in super-smooth frequency response and nicely neutral tonality, and they’re very close to being the complete solution.”
TechRadar (Simon Lucas)
“most B&W headphones tend to approximate a comparable V-shaped sound”
RTINGS
