By aspect — in detail
Sources split. Every magazine — SOS, MusicRadar, MusicTech, Bonedo, AMAZONA — rates the custom NI semi-weighted keybed at or near the best in its price class, some finding it hard to tell from the S-Series' Fatar bed, and a run of owners agrees. A distinct camp finds it springy, noisy and — the real sticking point — inconsistent in velocity: quiet unless you hit hard, jumping between soft and loud, and not adjustable on the hardware beyond a fixed-velocity switch. No aftertouch. If even dynamics matter to you, try it in person or plan on a velocity-curve plug-in in your DAW.
Measured
Spec: 49 full-size semi-weighted, velocity-sensitive keys on NI's own (non-Fatar) keybed; no aftertouch. The manual's only velocity control is Fixed Velocity (Shift + Octave down), which pins every note at 127; NI support confirmed in 2022 that no velocity curve or sensitivity setting exists for the A-Series and none is planned.
⚠ vs. listeners — NI bills it as a 'best-in-class' keybed and the feel largely earns that; the velocity mapping is what the critical camp objects to — the same keys, judged on a different axis.
Where it splits
The best keys at the price — solid semi-weighted feel, close to the S-Series61%
“While the S-Series Fatar keyboard is absent and there's no aftertouch, the feel of the keys is not all that different. I can't think of a comparable alternative at this price.”
Simon Sherbourne · Sound on Sound
Controls
Contested · 12 srcSources split on one detail. The eight touch-sensitive endless knobs (touch one and the OLED shows its parameter and value), the four-way push encoder and the full-size pitch/mod wheels are the same parts as the S-Series and draw consistent praise; the small OLED is legible but shows only a name and a value. The buttons are the recurring gripe: hard plastic instead of the S-Series' rubber, with a loud, sharp click that magazines note in passing and some owners find bad enough to avoid the buttons altogether. A few also find the 4-D encoder wobbly.
Measured
Spec: eight touch-sensitive endless encoders, a four-directional push encoder, pitch and mod wheels, transport plus Loop/Metro/Tempo/Undo/Quantize/Ideas/Scale/Arp/Shift buttons, octave and fixed-velocity buttons, and a single small OLED (about 24 × 7 mm). Knobs, keys, pedals and buttons are assignable in the MIDI Assignment Editor of the standalone Komplete Kontrol app (added in 2.3.0; not in Controller Editor and not from the plug-in).
Where it splits
S-Series-grade knobs, encoder and wheels at a third of the price70%
“The wheels, rotary encoders and main four-way encoder feel like they're the same components as on the S.”
Simon Sherbourne · Sound on Sound
Hard, loud, cheap-feeling buttons — and a wobbly encoder for some30%
“du clic discret qui était probablement obtenu par un amortissement, on passe à un clic bien plus audible qui fait plus cheap”
Arnaud Cueff (Los Teignos) · Audiofanzine
Integration
Contested · 16 srcSources split, and the split tracks where you live. Inside the Komplete Kontrol plug-in the keyboard auto-switches into NKS mode, browses tagged presets with audio previews and lands every important parameter on the knobs — SOS calls it the killer feature rivals still haven't cracked — and transport/track control works well in Logic, GarageBand, Live and Maschine (Cubase/Nuendo, Studio One, Pro Tools and FL Studio were added later). Outside that world the same hardware frustrates: knobs and buttons that do nothing until the right software is installed and set up, Windows units not being recognised, one-off setup fights, and the arp/scale/chord tools only working through Komplete Kontrol. Some 2018 complaints — no MIDI editor, no Cubase — have since been fixed.
Measured
Spec: NKS pre-mapping and browsing via the Komplete Kontrol plug-in/standalone app; advanced host integration listed for Logic Pro 10.3.1+, GarageBand 10.2+, Ableton Live 10.05+, Cubase/Nuendo, Studio One 4.5+, Pro Tools 2021.10+ and (per NI's setup guide) FL Studio 21.2.3+; MCU support since KK 2.1.3; Maschine integration. Bitwig auto-setup is MK3-only. Still supported by Komplete Kontrol 3.x — only the S-Series MK1 lost support in October 2023.
⚠ vs. listeners — The supported-DAW list has roughly doubled since the 2018 reviews, so 'no Cubase / no Pro Tools' verdicts are dated; Reaper, Bitwig, Reason and Digital Performer users still get a generic MIDI keyboard.
Where it splits
Inside NKS and a supported DAW it's the killer feature — browse, preview, pre-mapped knobs60%
“If you focus a track that contains the Komplete Kontrol plug-in, the keyboard will automatically switch to native KK mode. As I've said in previous reviews, this is the killer integration feature that other similar products are yet to crack.”
Simon Sherbourne · Sound on Sound
Outside NI's ecosystem it's a half-useful controller with a setup tax40%
“Wer keine NI-Produkte besitzt oder nutzen möchte, fährt mit anderen Controllerkeyboards sicherlich besser, ansonsten bilden die Modelle A25, A49 und A61 die Budget-Variante der NI-Controllerkeyboards.”
Felix Thoma · AMAZONA.de
Software
Strong consensus · 9 srcA strength no source disputes. The launch bundle (Monark, Reaktor Prism, The Gentleman, Scarbee Mark I, Maschine Essentials, the free Komplete Start) was called generous for the price by every magazine and by owners; NI now ships a voucher for a Komplete Select edition plus Ableton Live Lite instead. Two honest caveats: existing Komplete owners gain little from it, and the Smart Play scale/chord/arp features live in the Komplete Kontrol software, not the keyboard, so they vanish in plain MIDI mode.
“Pour ne rien gâcher, le bundle de logiciels fourni est, comme souvent avec Native, relativement généreux.”
Arnaud Cueff (Los Teignos) · Audiofanzine
“All the software it comes with is absolutely killer (Komplete Kontrol/Ableton) and the keys feel pretty good too.”
Mountainlynx Maine Coons · Amazon (verified purchase)
“Overall, I am very impressed with the variety of sounds/software that comes bundled with it.”
Jennifer S. · Sweetwater customer review
Measured
Spec: registration unlocks the Komplete Kontrol software, a Komplete Select edition voucher (Beats, Band or Electronic — since 2024; the 2018 bundle was Monark, Reaktor Prism, The Gentleman, Scarbee Mark I and Maschine Essentials, about 9.7 GB) and Ableton Live Lite.
Connectivity
Moderate · 11 srcConsistently the weakest axis, and nobody argues otherwise: a single USB-B port (bus-powered, and it will run stand-alone from a USB host) plus one ¼-inch pedal jack assignable to sustain — no 5-pin MIDI in or out, no CV, no expression-pedal input, no power switch. Anyone with hardware synths, a second pedal or a need for a volume pedal is pointed at the S-Series. One owner also notes the pedal can't follow the keybed's MIDI channel when templates change channels.
“The keyboards have no built in MIDI ports, but are capable of stand-alone operation over USB.”
Simon Sherbourne · Sound on Sound
“Fünfpolige MIDI-Buchsen gibt es hier nicht. Wer diese benötigt und ggf. auch ein zweites Pedal nutzen möchte, muss entsprechend zur S-Serie greifen.”
Felix Thoma · AMAZONA.de
“The pedal input only supports a sustain pedal, not a volume pedal, so I can't use that for expressive control.”
Mikey Micheletti · Sweetwater customer review
Measured
Spec: USB 2.0 Type-B, bus-powered (cable included); one ¼-inch TRS pedal input assignable to sustain; Kensington lock slot. No DIN MIDI, no CV/gate, no expression input, no power switch.
Portability
Moderate · 7 srcLighter and narrower than the S-Series because the screens are gone, USB-bus-powered, and light enough that MusicTech carried it upstairs under one arm; it's a full-size 49 all the same — 82 cm wide and 4 kg — so it's a car-and-studio keyboard, not a backpack one, and one desk-bound owner found it bulkier than it needs to be.
“The A49 on test was a ’carry up the stairs under one arm’ job when I took it in my studio which, probably because I’m always lugging gear around, I see as a good thing.”
Andy Jones · MusicTech
“I've got this on a desk, and it seems bulkier than it really needs to be.”
Mikey Micheletti · Sweetwater customer review
Measured
Spec: 820 × 257 × 89 mm (32.3 × 10.1 × 3.5 in), 4 kg (8.8 lb); USB 2.0 bus-powered, no external supply.
Broadly praised: an all-plastic chassis that magazines and owners call surprisingly solid — no flex, no creak, the wheels and knobs lifted from the S-Series, rubber feet that keep it planted. Two dissents form a small tail: owners who move to an S find the A noticeably less sturdy (softer pots, cheaper-feeling 4-D encoder), and a handful report failures — a unit with erratic and dead keys, a wobbly and creaking encoder, an OLED dying after five months, a firmware update that never took.
Measured
Spec: all-plastic chassis, 4 kg, six rubber feet, Kensington slot; the pitch/mod wheels, encoders and 4-D encoder are the same parts as the S-Series MK2, the buttons are hard plastic rather than the S-Series' rubber.
Where it splits
Solid, S-Series-grade plastic construction for the money84%
“The A-Series keyboards are great quality for the money, and offer instant gratification alongside Komplete Kontrol.”
Simon Sherbourne · Sound on Sound
Sources split along the same line as integration. Every magazine calls it an outstanding deal — pro-grade hardware plus a real software bundle for under $220 — and most owners agree. The dissent comes from people who aren't in NI's world or fought the software: Amazon's own value tally runs more negative than positive, and NI's forum holds owners who regret it or call it the worst gear they've bought. Two things reframe the question now: new stock is drying up (NI's store, Thomann and Amazon are all out), and a used A49 or a clearance S49 MK2 can land within a few dollars of each other.
Measured
Launched September 2018 at $209 / £159; $219 list at NI (currently out of stock there), $219 at Sweetwater in late 2023, CAD 279 at Long & McQuade; Thomann has delisted it and Amazon's listing is unavailable. Amazon's per-topic tallies: value for money 5 positive / 8 negative, DAW integration 9 / 5, build quality 5 / 0.
Where it splits
An outstanding deal if you use Komplete/NKS — hardware and software for the price of a plain controller79%
“The MkIII and A-Series keyboards lose the hardware-focused workflow but bring an unprecedented level of portability and affordability to Maschine and Komplete.”
Simon Sherbourne · Sound on Sound
Outside NI's world it's a regret — a $100 keyboard does the MIDI job with less fuss21%
“So far I am regretting the purchase of the A49 based on frustrations with the Komplete Kontrol software.”
logicpromachine · NI Community