Band: opinion spread · Dot: weighted average
Sources split three ways, and the largest camp has moved since launch. Everyone agrees the original Clear's low- and mid-treble peaks were pulled down; they disagree on what that left. The biggest group — RTINGS, crinacle, Joshua Valour, headphones.com's listener — hears it as dark, recessed or veiled, with cymbals and sibilants dulled. A smaller group calls it the fix: smoother, easier to listen to, the old 'metallic' zing gone. A third still hears something hot up top — What Hi-Fi's initial hard edge, Resolve's too-strong contrast above 10 kHz, and GoldenSound's fatiguing resonance around 18 kHz, which he warns younger listeners may find a deal-breaker.
Measured
Against each rig's own HD 600 (RTINGS: HD 650), the 4–6 kHz band sits 7.4 dB lower on oratory1990's GRAS 43AG, 6.4 dB on RTINGS' HMS II.3, 3.4 dB on SAI's GRAS 43AG-4, 1.0 dB on Super* Review and 0.7 dB on Kuulokenurkka's KB501X rig; 6–10 kHz is 1.7–5.3 dB lower on four of the five. Above 10 kHz four rigs sit level with or 1.4–3.1 dB above the HD 600 (oratory's sits 3.4 dB below). On oratory's rig the Mg is about 4 dB darker than the OG Clear from 4–10 kHz. Resolve (GRAS 43AG plus in-ear mics) finds the mid-treble 'noticeably pulled back' and the band above 10 kHz significantly elevated; RTINGS notes treble delivery varies with fit and seal.
vs. listeners — The rigs disagree by up to ~6–7 dB in exactly the disputed band — far more than they disagree on the HD 600 — so pairs differ, not just ears. crinacle's unit measured warmer and honkier than others until he swapped pads; owners report pairs whose two pads had different foam density; and Focal told Resolve the darker curve he and jude measured is the intended one. 'Dark' and 'smooth' can both be accurate reports of different pairs. The 18 kHz fatigue GoldenSound describes sits above where most rigs are reliable and above many adults' hearing.
“their treble range is a bit recessed, which veils the upper harmonics of vocals while sibilants are dull”
RTINGS
“I think that the new Clear MG tuning is an improvement over the original as the changes to the treble I think make it quite a bit easier to listen to”
Headphones.com (Chrono)
“Initial listening shows up a slightly hard and sharp edge in the lower treble region, but this eases off in use to leave an etched but informative sound.”
What Hi-Fi?
