Band: opinion spread · Dot: weighted average
Sources split on the headline claim. A majority — the German studio tests, Crinacle's ranking, MKBHD, Head-Fi's twister6 and most owners — hear a flat, neutral, honest monitor; a large minority — Tape Op, SoundGuys, RTINGS, MusicRadar and Z Reviews — hear a coloured curve, whether scooped, consumer-bright or mid-forward. The rigs show why both are reported: close to target through the bass and mids on the GRAS rigs, clearly lifted at 8–10.5 kHz everywhere.
Measured
oratory1990 (GRAS, vs Harman over-ear 2018): within about 3 dB of target up to 2 kHz, +2 to +4 dB from 2–5 kHz, on target at 6–7 kHz, +2 to +3 dB at 8–10.5 kHz. Crinacle (GRAS) puts it 3–4 dB above his HD 650 around 2 and 4 kHz and 7–11 dB above it at 8–9 kHz; InnerFidelity's data has it 6–12 dB above its HD 600 at 7–10.5 kHz. Tape Op measured a −9 dB carve-out from 900 Hz to 3.6 kHz and a +6 dB peak at 10.5 kHz.
vs. listeners — Both camps are reading real data. Against a target, the M70x tracks closer than the M50x does in the bass and mids — the 'flat' impression, especially next to an M50x — while every rig shows a top octave lifted well above neutral, which is what the 'not flat' camp hears. Tape Op's midrange carve-out does not appear on either GRAS rig, so how recessed the mids sound also depends on the rig and the seal.
“The most neutral of the M-series.”
Crinacle, headphone ranking list (B−, 'Neutral')
“To put it simply, the ATH-M70x's voicing is decidedly "scooped" and puts strong emphasis on the highs.”
Andy Hong, Tape Op #113
