Band: opinion spread · Dot: weighted average
The headline disagreement, and it is not about taste so much as about two different experiences of the same keyboard. Every magazine that put hands on one describes a springy, responsive full-size action and treats it as the reason to buy — Produce Like A Pro calls it where the V49 MKII shines. Against that sits a smaller but consistent group of owners reporting a specific failure: the keys register almost nothing unless struck hard, with no in-between. Nobody claims the action feels premium, there is no aftertouch on any V MKII, and — unlike several rivals at the price — there is no way to change the velocity curve on the unit itself.
Measured
Alesis specs 49 full-size velocity-sensitive synth-action keys — Sound On Sound describes them as 'waterfall' keys — with no aftertouch, and the user guide documents no on-board velocity-curve control: the only listed way to retune key response is the free downloadable V49 MKII Editor.
vs. listeners — That software-only adjustment is what both camps talk past. A response that reads as 'lively' to one player and 'super quiet' to another may be the same default curve landing differently, and on many rival boards you would simply change it with a key combination. Here you cannot: the editor is the only route, it is delivered through a registered Alesis account rather than the box, and Alesis's own Windows 11 compatibility table still lists the V MKII Editor as 'In Testing' while listing the hardware itself as Supported. So an owner who finds the curve wrong may have no fix at all on their machine.
“Lively keyboard action is responsive and springy.”
Jono Buchanan · MusicRadar
“It works but the notes are SUPER quiet unless I slam my fingers on the keys.”
u/Sergeant_Arcade · r/MIDIcontrollers
