Band: opinion spread · Dot: weighted average
Sources split on quality, not quantity — everyone hears a lot of it. One camp calls the shelf big but controlled, with no bleed into the mids; the other hears it as over-emphasised and a step slow, tubby in the mid-bass and smearing busier tracks. The graphs side with the second camp: sub-bass lands on the Harman line, but the 100–300 Hz region runs 3–4 dB above it, which is exactly where 'tubby' and 'warm' live.
Measured
Seven IEC-711-clone rigs agree within about 2 dB: normalised at 500 Hz the shelf sits near +9 dB from 20–50 Hz, +7.5 dB at 100 Hz and +4.4 dB at 200 Hz. Against the Harman IE 2019 target that is sub-bass on the line and mid-bass 3.3 dB over at 100 Hz, 4.0 dB over at 200 Hz and 2.6 dB over at 300 Hz.
vs. listeners — The majority 'no bleed' camp is describing a set whose 100–300 Hz region measures 3–4 dB above target on every rig; the minority 'tubby' reading (Loomis Johnson hears a distinct tubbiness and a slow attack) is the one the graphs support. Seal decides how much of the shelf you get, which is the likeliest reason the two camps exist.
“Bass is in fact a bit abundant, but it’s never bloated or aggressive, so it stays in check and blends nicely with the rest of the sound, without ever covering the mids.”
Riccardo Robecchi, Soundphile Review
“Bass is over-emphasized compared to our preference, but many in-ears do that.”
Christian Thomas, SoundGuys
