Band: opinion spread · Dot: weighted average
Sources split, and the split runs along an identifiable line. Most magazine and press reviews — largely written on units Audio-Technica supplied — describe a balanced, uncoloured reference tuning. The measurers, the headphone-specialist reviewers and most enthusiast owners describe a mild V-shape or a bright tilt: lifted bass and lifted treble either side of a neutral midrange. The measurements back the second reading.
Measured
Seven rigs (GRAS, B&K 5128 and KEMAR-pinna clones) also hold the Sennheiser HD 560S or HD 600, and they agree: the 200 Hz–2 kHz midrange tracks the Sennheisers within about 1–2 dB, the 50–100 Hz bass sits 2–4.4 dB above the HD 560S, and the 6–10 kHz band sits roughly 3–6 dB above it (3–10 dB above the HD 600). The flatbed rig reaches the same picture, and one rig's two samples differ by about 4 dB in that treble band, so units vary.
vs. listeners — The rigs show a tuning that departs from flat at both ends, so 'dead neutral' is not what the driver is doing. The neutral camp is right about the midrange, which really is level and uncoloured; the split looks less like taste than like who was listening — loan-unit reviews written for studio buyers on one side, people comparing it directly with Sennheisers on the other.
“The open-backed design, coupled with a balanced sound, makes for a great listening experience.”
Oliver Haslam, AppleInsider
“So people with a preference for elevated treble and bass will prefer the stock ATH-R50x.”
Solderdude, DIY-Audio-Heaven
