Band: opinion spread · Dot: weighted average
Sources split on the same graph. One camp — RTINGS, DIY-Audio-Heaven, Home Studio Basics and most long-term owners — hears a flat, honest, neutral-leaning tuning that is refreshingly free of bass bloat and a good first 'audiophile' sound. The other — Crinacle, Earmass, Headphonesty and the sharper Reddit and Head-Fi critics — hears the rolled-off bass and the 6 kHz peak as a cold, thin, intensely bright signature that does not deserve its HD 600 comparisons. Both agree it is bright of neutral and that a bass shelf plus a treble cut brings it a long way.
Measured
Eight rigs draw the same curve: on-target from 100 Hz to 1.5 kHz, a 3–8 dB dip centred at 2.0–2.5 kHz, and a 3–9 dB peak at 5.9–6.5 kHz (oratory1990 GRAS: −2.9 dB at 2.1 kHz, +6.9 dB at 6.2 kHz against Harman 2018; Crinacle KEMAR: −4.3 dB at 2.5 kHz, +9.4 dB at 6.3 kHz). Against an HD 600 on the same rig it sits 2–3 dB lower at 2–3 kHz and 2–9 dB higher at 5–8 kHz — the physical basis of both 'neutral' and 'bright'. RTINGS scores the signature 'Flat' with treble 'Balanced'; Crinacle labels it 'Bright' with a C tone grade.
vs. listeners — The graph supports both readings: the midrange really is neutral, and the top end really is elevated. Which one dominates depends on listening level (Earmass hears it turn 'really bright' as the volume goes up), on how sensitive your ears are to a 6 kHz peak, and on the reference — owners upgrading to an R70x or Edition XS come back describing it as thinner and more sibilant than they remembered.
“If you want to get into the audiophile sphere, these cans are a good start, thanks to their flat and neutral sound.”
RTINGS (Sam Vafaei, Vanessa McCuaig)
“Decent imaging chops held back by its intensely bright presentation and below-average resolution.”
Crinacle (headphone ranking list)
