Band: opinion spread · Dot: weighted average
The core of the device and its one genuinely divided axis. The build of the controls is widely praised — eight smooth 60mm faders, 24 firm endless encoders with per-encoder RGB LEDs, 16 buttons and a dedicated transport section — and endless encoders neatly kill the parameter 'jump' that plagued the old pots. Extended-use reviewers call them satisfying and consistent. The split is over live/DAW usability: a substantive minority find the endless encoders' DAW-mode sensitivity sluggish (it can take almost three full turns to sweep a parameter, which firmware 1.1 lets you fix with an acceleration setting — but only in Custom Modes, not the DAW mixer/control modes), and there are recurring gripes that the encoders are a touch stiff, have no push/click or touch, and lack a value-indicator LED ring, so you read values off the tiny OLED. Faders have no LEDs at all.
Measured
Novation's spec: 24 endless rotary encoders (each with an RGB LED that dims/brightens to hint position), eight 60mm throw faders, and 16 buttons (two below each fader). Firmware 1.1 added adjustable encoder-acceleration curves and a fader 'pickup' mode — but the acceleration setting applies only to Custom Modes, not the DAW Mixer/Control modes. The encoders have no push/click or touch sensing, and the faders have no LEDs.
“The encoders are especially satisfying—they don't wobble, they track consistently, and the RGB feedback makes it easy to stay oriented even when switching between modes.”
Magnetic Magazine
“On the XL 3, it takes almost three full rotations to get through the range. It's completely impractical for live performance or fast mixing.”
u/metafysikz · r/Novation
