Band: opinion spread · Dot: weighted average
Sources split on the same measured top end. The larger camp — most editorial reviewers and many owners — hears a lifted, airy, sparkling treble that stays clean and non-fatiguing. A third of the weight hears it as gritty, sharp or sibilant: Resolve, SoundGuys, ASR members and a run of owners who returned or sold it over the treble, often citing rock and metal or poor recordings. A small third camp (SoundStage!'s Brent Butterworth, one Head-Fi owner) hears it as relaxed. The split tracks listener sensitivity, music and source, not unit variation: the peaks are narrow, so they catch some ears and recordings and miss others.
Measured
Nine rigs agree on the shape: against an HD 600/6XX on the same rig the 109 Pro has a narrow notch near 6 kHz, a peak around 7 kHz (+2 to +7.5 dB) and a 12–16 kHz lift that ranges from +5 dB (oratory1990's GRAS) to +17 dB (Super* Review's seatings); soundnews measures ~8 dB at ~8.5 kHz on EARS. Against the Edition XS it carries 2–7 dB less 2–8 kHz energy on every rig with both. SoundGuys says it 'emphasizes treble frequencies more than our headphone preference curve'; Brent Butterworth's GRAS graph looks 'pretty typical for an open-back'. Owners tame it with EQ, AKG K240 foam discs in the pads (Super* Review measures −6.4 dB at 8 kHz) or thicker third-party pads.
vs. listeners — The peaks are real but narrow and high, which is why the same unit reads as 'sparkle' to one listener and 'sibilance' to another. Owners on both sides report younger or treble-sensitive listeners, rock/metal and hot recordings, and bright sources as the trigger; claims that it 'settles' after 50–100 hours come from owners, and ASR members dispute them.
“While some treble enhancement is present, it never gets harsh or sibilant.”
Pragmatic Audio
“Some uneven and gritty treble presentation but also reasonably incisive”
Resolve (headphones.com ranking list)
“I definitely felt like the treble was dialed down a decibel or two overall”
SoundStage! Solo (Brent Butterworth)
